Store Hours: M-F 8am-5pm CST
Online eBay Store Open 24/7/365!

Welcome to Butler’s Self-Service!

The #1 Auto Salvage Yard  in the Pensacola, FL & Milton, FL area

*** Important Hollywood Location Update ***

For over 20 years, Butler U-Pull-It has proudly served the community in Pensacola, Florida and the surrounding areas from our 16-acre auto salvage yard at 2730 Hollywood Ave Pensacola, FL 32505. We sincerely appreciate you, and each and every one of our loyal patrons that visited this location over the years. However, we do have some potentially shocking news for you.

Butler U-Pull-It Pensacola Florida’s Hollywood Ave location has closed. Good news though? We have two better locations to serve you with in Pensacola, FL and Milton, FL! 🥳

Our family owned-and-operated company is proud of its enormous inventory of used truck parts and used auto body parts, including header and nose panels, radiator supports, A/C condensers, taillights, radiators, headlights, grills and lots more at both of these incredible locations. Save Up To 75% With Butler’s Used Auto Parts everyday!

So if you’re in the mood to shop local and save big, come see us at one of our 2 convenient locations and shop acres of used auto parts, where we can give you the interchange, color and row number of the vehicle you’re looking for, or do it for you!

At Butler Self-Service, new vehicles arrive daily, so our inventory is always fresh. Customers can donate old clunkers for a tax write-off or you can pick up a new-to-you car that has only the best parts inside. If you’re looking for the best prices on used auto body parts in the Pensacola, FL or Milton, FL area, then look no further!

Visit us today at one of our two great locations listed below, or shop online at ButlerAutoRecycling.com for inexpensive car parts or to learn more about the benefits of vehicle donation.

Thanks for visiting our website today and we look forward to meeting you in person soon!


One Great Company.
Two Convenient Locations.

- Full Service -

Pensacola Hours:
M-F 8am-5pm CST

Physical & Mailing Address:
6401 North Palafox St.
Pensacola, Florida 32503

Local Phone:

- Self Service -

Milton Hours:
M-F 8am-5pm CST

Physical & Mailing Address:
5505 Industrial Blvd.
Milton, Florida 32584

Local Phone: 
1-850-472-3120, then press 3

Frequently Asked Questions

How long have you been in business?

Butler Auto Recycling has been in business since 1977. We have served generations of Gulf Coast residents over the years and look forward to continuing to do so for years to come. 

How do you differentiate yourself from other businesses in your category and area?

We inventory all of our used and new tires in a computer system which provides real-time inventory to our customers. Our prices include a 90 day warranty. We try to take the guessing game out of what the true price is.

How many locations do you have and do you have plans to expand?

We currently have two convenient locations in Pensacola and Milton, but have plans to expand in the future to help better serve you.

What type of payments do you accept?

We accept cash, check, Visa, Mastercard, American Express, Discover

What Are You Looking For Today?

Whether you are looking for new or used tires, a replacement engine or transmission, or any used auto parts backed by a warranty and company you can trust, click the button to search our entire online inventory for the parts you are looking for.

Can’t Find the Auto Parts You’re Looking For?

No worries! Call our team of specialists now to see if your part is in stock, but not listed yet, or to see if we can special order it for you ASAP!


Skip to content